Abstract

We provide an extensive study assessing whether a prior wavelet-based denoising step enhances the forecast accuracy of standard forecasting models. Many combinations of attribute values of the thresholding (denoising) algorithm are explored together with several traditional forecasting models used in economic time series forecasting. The results are evaluated using M3 competition yearly time series. We conclude that the performance of a forecasting model combined with the prior denoising step is generally not recommended, which implies that a straightforward generalisation of some of the results available in the literature (which found the denoising step to be beneficial) is not possible. Even if cross-validation is used to select the value of the threshold, a superior performance of the forecasting model with the prior denoising step does not generally follow.

Highlights

  • Many business, economic, and financial time series can be considered to be buried in noise

  • Since a prior wavelet-based denoising step combined with the random walk method is similar to simple exponential smoothing, the difference being in the way noise is removed, we examine the performance of the prior waveletbased denoising step combined with the random walk method in more detail in our paper

  • We provide an introduction to the maximal overlap discrete wavelet transform (MODWT) filters (Section 2.1) so that we can introduce the MODWT (Section 2.2) and the denoising techniques based on the MODWT (Section 3)

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Economic, and financial time series can be considered to be buried in noise. (a) we explore several combinations of the attributes of the wavelet-based denoising algorithm, as well as (b) many forecasting models/methods and (c), assess the performance using many economic, demographic, industrial, and financial time series. Since a prior wavelet-based denoising step combined with the random walk method is similar to simple exponential smoothing, the difference being in the way noise is removed (see Ferbar et al, 2009), we examine the performance of the prior waveletbased denoising step (namely the one that uses time series cross-validation to decide on the amount of noise to be removed) combined with the random walk method in more detail in our paper.

Literature Review
Maximal Overlap Discrete Wavelet Transform
MODWT Filters
MODWT Coefficients and MODWT of Level
Thresholding of Wavelet Coefficients
MODWT-based Approach to Thresholding
Thresholding Rules
Boundaries and Boundary Conditions
Threshold Selection
Model Misspecification
Evaluation of Forecast Accuracy for Models with the Prior Denoising Step
M3 Competition Time Series
Evaluation of Forecast Accuracy
Attributes of the Thresholding Algorithm
Descriptive Results
Significance of the Results
Comparison of SES and RW Combined with Cross-validation
Conclusions
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call