Tillage, fertilizer type, and plant residue input impacts on soil carbon sequestration rates on a Japanese Andosol

Abstract

ABSTRACTTo identify efficient field management practices for enhanced soil carbon sequestration suited to crop rotation-based Andosol fields in northern Japan, the impacts of a combination of tillage, fertilizer type, and plant residue input on soil carbon sequestration rates were studied in a 4-year field experiment (April 2007 to March 2011). The rates of changes in soil organic carbon over the entire study period were determined by soil carbon stock change and by net ecosystem carbon budget. Across eight field management treatments and two replicates for each treatment, the rates of changes in soil organic carbon determined by net ecosystem carbon budget were positively correlated with the rates determined by soil carbon stock change (r = 0.766, n = 16). The arithmetic means of the rates determined by net ecosystem carbon budget (1.24 Mg C ha−1 year−1) were greater than those determined by soil carbon stock change (−0.18 Mg C ha−1 year−1) because decomposing crop residues and composted cattle manure in soil were included in the calculation of the net ecosystem carbon budget but were excluded in the calculation of soil carbon stock change (decomposing crop residues and composted cattle manure in soil samples were removed by sieving in measuring the soil carbon stock change). Both methods led to the same conclusion that soil carbon sequestration was significantly enhanced by composted cattle manure application and increased input of plant carbon from crop residues and green manure but was not enhanced by reduced tillage. The p values for net ecosystem carbon budget were smaller than those for soil carbon stock change in analysis of variance; therefore, the net ecosystem carbon budget was more sensitive to field management practice than the soil carbon stock change.