Threespine stickleback aggregations create a potential predation refuge for sockeye salmon fry

Abstract

Coho salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) frequently consume sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) fry in Chignik Lake, Alaska, but have never been observed to consume threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus), which are often closely associated with sockeye fry. Because coho salmon are visual predators and appear to avoid sticklebacks, a series of experiments was conducted in net pens to determine whether juvenile sockeye associated with threespine sticklebacks experienced less prédation than sockeye without sticklebacks and whether prey size affected prédation rates. Significantly fewer sockeye fry by coho were consumed in the pen containing 60 sticklebacks [Formula: see text] than in the 30-stickleback (4.7 fry/day) and 0-stickleback (4.4 fry/day) pens. An identical experiment with large, yearling sockeye (rather than sticklebacks) did not reveal a significant effect (p = 0.28), although there was a tendency for fewer large fry to be consumed when yearlings were abundant. A third experiment demonstrated predation rates on fry that were 45% lower in the presence of sticklebacks (1.2 fry/day) than in the presence of yearling sockeye (2.2 fry/day). Large sockeye fry (37–44 mm) consumed by coho declined steadily from about 36 to 29 to 22% of the total number of fry eaten as the number of sticklebacks or yearling sockeye increased from 0 to 30 to 60, respectively. These data suggest that the presence of threespine sticklebacks may reduce predation by coho on juvenile sockeye, especially those sockeye similar in size to sticklebacks.