Three-dimensional Echocardiography Is Not Essential for Intraoperative Assessment of Mitral Regurgitation

Abstract

The problem is not what you see on intraoperative echocardiography; it is what you do not see. Intraoperative transesophageal echocardiography and 3-dimensional (3D) echocardiography provide useful information for the surgeon performing mitral valve surgery, but they are not indispensable. We should consider the outstanding results of the pioneer of mitral valve repair, Professor Alain Carpentier. A report of very late results (>20 years) of the earliest series (1970–1984) of mitral valve repair is informative.1 Even without the availability of intraoperative transesophageal echocardiography, the late results were outstanding. At 20 years, freedom from reoperation was 96.9% for patients with posterior leaflet prolapse and 86.2% for patients with anterior prolapse. At the last follow-up (median, 17 years) 15% had moderate or worse mitral regurgitation. An experienced mitral valve surgeon can achieve durable high-quality results without any echocardiography, so 3D echocardiography is not essential. Response by Tsang and Lang on p 658 What is essential for mitral valve surgery? The fundamental elements from the surgical standpoint are the same whether the procedure is performed through a sternotomy or a minimally invasive incision or is robotically assisted. Achieving good surgical exposure is paramount.2 Numerous surgical techniques, including the type and location of venous cannulation, the atrial incision, retraction of the atrial wall, sutures to help rotate the valve and improve visualization, and occasionally the use of an instrument pushing from outside the heart to facilitate exposure of commissures or the anterior leaflet, are routine practice to optimally visualize the valve. Unless the surgeon is expert in the first step of the procedure, results will be compromised. A perfect 3D echocardiography image of the valve will not compensate for poor exposure. Although real-time 3D color echocardiography is useful, there is nothing more realistic than real-time 3D color visualization through 2.5-power loupes by the …