Thermodynamic and structural description of relative solubility of the flavonoid rutin by DFT calculations and molecular dynamics simulations

Abstract

Understanding the solubility of flavonoids is of relevance in view of the broad application such as antioxidant and antitumor agents. The solubility of flavonoid rutin has been experimentally investigated in a homologous series of alcohols, acetone, n-heptane and water solvents. In this work theoretical evaluation of Gibbs free energy of solvation was performed at the Density Functional Theory (DFT) and Molecular Dynamics (MD) levels, with the ωB97x-D functional and multistate Bennett acceptance ratio (MBAR) method, respectively. The degree of solubility of a given solute among various solvents is dictated by solute-solvent interactions, which may be represented by the solvation energy. Our calculated relative energy values due to solvent effects, using quantum chemical methods (PCM and SMD solvent models) do not follow strictly the observed solubility trend. However, the PCM model including solute-solvent dispersion interaction, solute-solvent repulsion interaction and solute cavitation energy contribution to the total energy (named DIS,REP,CAV) yielded an overall agreement with experimental solubility profile, with exception of ethanol solvent. A similar satisfactory accordance with experiment was found for MBresults, with a discrepancy also found for 1-butanol, which deserve further investigation. Analysis of spatial and radial distribution functions (SDF and RDF) for pure solvents and the analysis of the contributions of vdW and electrostatic terms for the total free energy reveal that a balance between dispersive and electrostatic interactions between the rutin and the solvent is necessary to solubilize the flavonoid, which corroborates with the values of these energy contributions to the solvation-free energy calculated by the MBAR method. The use of explicit solvent molecules in DFT calculations is precluded due to the size, flexibility, and many sites for solvent interactions of rutin molecule. Our results indicate that in general DFT-PCM (DIS,REP,CAV) and MBAR levels of calculations can satisfactorily predict the solvation free energy and solubility trend for flavonoid rutin along a series of solvents, and also provide a reasonable estimate of relative solubilities of other flavonoids, information that can be relevant for further molecular modeling studies.