Thermal insulation and SIDS—an investigation of selected ‘Eastern’ and ‘Western’ infant bedding combinations

Abstract

Background Differences in the incidence of SIDS between ‘Western’ and ‘Eastern’ countries has been attributed to cultural practices, which may affect the infants care and thermal environment. Aim The purpose of this work was to estimate for selected ‘commonly’ used bedding, sleep positions and practices in Japan, Korea and New Zealand, the intrinsic ‘dry’ thermal resistance of bedding. Insulation levels are also discussed in the context of published information about the thermal environment in which the bedding is likely to be used. Method Selected Japanese, Korean and New Zealand bedding was loosely tucked over an infant manikin in the lateral, prone and supine sleep positions. Thickness in use was measured, and intrinsic ‘dry’ thermal resistance estimated using the Wilson Laing model which accommodates the effect on insulation of the three-dimensional arrangement of bedding combinations during use. Results and discussion Thickness of under- and upper-bedding varied among countries with thickness and estimated ‘dry’ thermal resistance of the upper-bedding affected by the type/combination of bedding and the infants sleep position. Insulation levels are discussed in relation to environmental conditions within and among countries and between seasons. Further information on thermal environments, bedding combinations used and care practices within both Asian and Western countries is needed. Conclusions ‘Eastern’ infants appear likely to be generally covered in bedding combinations of greater insulation than those used to cover ‘Western’ infants in comparable seasons. Differences existed between insulation of the Japanese and Korean bedding combinations investigated. Lower rates of SIDS apparent in ‘Asian’ populations do not appear attributable to use of lower levels of bedding insulation only.