Therian Teeth of Unusual Design from the Mid-Cretaceous (Albian–Cenomanian) Cedar Mountain Formation of Utah

Abstract

Enigmatic, abundant mammalian teeth from the medial Cretaceous of Utah are shown to belong to antemolar loci, based on dentulous jaw fragments; isolated teeth representing several upper premolar loci and the reconstructed c-p4 series are identified. Three species, differing in size and morphology, can be recognized. Morphological appropriateness, relative abundance, and distributional data indicate that the teeth can be referred with some confidence to the three symmetrodonts known from the Cedar Mountain Formation: Spalacolestes cretulablatta, S. inconcinnus, and Spalacotheridium noblei. If the specimens represent replacement or successional teeth, they are strikingly atypical for Mesozoic mammals, particularly in their low crowns and high degree of molarization at posterior loci. Jaw structure, wear pattern, and aspects of tooth morphology (e.g., proportions, degree of molarization, enamel thickness) favor the alternative hypothesis that these teeth are deciduous. Diphyodonty at all antemolar loci is generally assumed to represent the primitive condition for mammals, though fossil evidence is scant; some of the earliest mammals are known to undergo replacement only at the last premolar locus, with ontogenetic loss (rather than replacement) mesially. Available evidence suggests that, like the eupantothere Dryolestes, North American spalacotheriid symmetrodonts probably underwent single replacement at most or all premolar loci and that the deciduous series became progressively more molariform distally, particularly at the p3–4 loci. Assuming that these teeth are deciduous, their great abundance in the Cedar Mountain Formation (and, apparently, elsewhere in the Cretaceous of North America) suggests that North American spalacotheriids were subject to unusually high juvenile mortality rates or, more probably, that succession at premolar loci took place late in ontogeny, compared to other Mesozoic mammals.