Abstract

Security studies literature neglects social media’s potential for lay actors to become influential within security debates. This article develops the concept of ‘security influencers’, bringing literature from marketing into the security debate to understand how social media enables individuals to ‘speak’ and contest security and how lay actors exert influence. Methodologically, this article applies a multi-methods approach to 27,367 tweets to identify and analyse the top four most influential actors in 48 hours following the 2017 bombings by keywords ‘Manchester’ and ‘Muslims’. This article builds a typology of security influencers nuancing definitions of the passive ‘security broadcaster’ and the active ‘security engager’, both of which emerge from obscurity or influence within non-security domains. Furthermore, a dichotomy emerges within influential messages and contestation; messages discussing Muslims in banal terms as diverse individuals register high levels of agreement, whereas those discussing Islam as a world religion receive more hostility and contestation.

Highlights

  • Security studies literature neglects social media’s potential for lay actors to become influential within security debates

  • This article intervenes in this understudied field posing the research question ‘How do security influencers emerge on social media?’ So, this article contributes to understandings of constructivist security through analysing social media outputs to understand who is influential in the security debate and how

  • We identify that non-security elites on social media become influential in ways similar to that of established security elites

Read more

Summary

Conceptualising Manchester and security challenges on social media

This article seeks to intervene within constructivist debates on security and requires grounding in both hierarchical theory such as the Copenhagen School and flatter Vernacular security studies discussion. This demonstrates how neither hierarchical nor flat theories accurately account for differentiation of actors’ influence when speaking about security on social media. To account for this question of influence and allow us to typologise the security influencer, we must account for digital marketing literature considering social influence and influencers. Manchester occurred within, and gave renewed impetus to debates about the place of Muslims in British society and the wider integration debate

Challenging constructivist understandings of security
Influencing constructivist understandings of terrorism
Manchester and British Muslims
Collecting Twitter data about security
Using Social Network Analysis to identify security influencers
Shares in graph
Sentiment analysis and contestation as influence
Sentiment neutral
Simple disagreement Islamic religion inherently violent Mourning
Conclusion
Findings
Author biographies

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.