Theoretical calculations and experimental data on spectral, kinetic and thermodynamic properties of Se∴N and S∴N three-electron-bonded, structurally stabilized σ2σ* radicals

Abstract

A complementary quantum mechanical and experimental study has been undertaken on the reactivity, formation and properties of Se∴N and S∴N σ2/σ* three-electron-bonded radical species, generated upon one-electron oxidation of selenomethionine, methionine and structurally related compounds. The quantum chemical calculations were based on density functional theory (DFT) hybrid B3LYP and BHandHLYP methods with basis sets ranging from 6-31G(d) to 6-311+G(d,p). Solvent effects, which play an important role concerning structure and energy of ground and excited states, were taken into account as dielectric continuum as well as explicit water molecules. They fully confirm new and previously obtained experimental results concerning the Vis/near-UV absorptions and thermodynamic stability. Special emphasis was put on a comparison between selenium and sulfur. The calculations clearly confirm the higher thermodynamic stability of the Se∴N radical species relative to the S∴N ones, and also corroborate the observed much higher kinetic stability of the former. Concerning optical absorptions, the calculations predict the Se∴N transients to exhibit a blue-shift by about 20 nm relative to the S-based analogues, confirming the few experimental data available so far. The theoretical study includes a comparison of various calculation levels and the influence of the solvent environment, by comparison with vacuum. New experimental data within the scope of this study have been obtained on intramolecularly-formed S∴N radical cation moieties, structurally stabilized by a rigid norbornane backbone. The methionine-related species, with an endo-2-amino, exo-2-carboxyl, and endo-6 methylthio substitution, for example, exhibits almost identical optical and kinetic stability properties as the corresponding species from free methionine. Its optical absorption depends on the protonation state of the carboxyl group, with λmax at 410 nm for the carboxylate (zwitterionic) form and at 390 nm for the overall cationic form with the protonated carboxyl group. The fast exponential decays with t1/2 of 490 ns and 2 μs pertain to the decarboxylation of the respective species. A much longer-lived S∴N species with t1/2 > 500 μs and second order decay kinetics (λmax 465 nm) was obtained from an endo-2-cyclohexylamino norbornane analogue which does not carry a carboxyl group. The methionine-based S∴N species is not stable anymore in vacuum and in low polarity solvents. This is explained by a decrease in stabilization energy of the 3-e-bond and a faster electron transfer from the carboxylate into the cationic 3-e-center. In conclusion, selenium enhances the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of its radical transients, relative to the sulfur analogues.