The Xu′s chart for prostate biopsy: a visual presentation of the added value of biomarkers to prostate-specific antigen for estimating detection rates of prostate cancer

Abstract

Elevated serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) level is the primary indication for prostate biopsy for detection of prostate cancer (PCa) in the modern era. The detection rate of PCa from biopsy is typically below 30%, especially among patients with PSA levels at 4–10 ng ml−1. In the past several years, additional biomarkers, such as Prostate Health Index, PCA3 and genetic risk score (GRS) derived from multiple PCa risk-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) have been shown to provide added value to PSA in discriminating prostate biopsy outcomes. However, the adoption rate of these novel biomarkers in clinics is low, largely due to poor understanding of the added value of novel biomarkers. To address this matter, we developed a chart to visually present (i) expected detection rates of PCa from biopsy with respect to PSA levels, and more importantly, (ii) a range of PCa detection rates at the same PSA levels when novel biomarkers are considered. This chart, called the Xu's chart for prostate biopsy, is not a formal risk prediction model; rather, a simple visual tool for urologists to communicate with their patients an initial evaluation of PCa detection rate based on their PSA levels and a possible recommendation for additional biomarkers. A more comprehensive evaluation of PCa risk using existing risk assessment tools such as nomograms can be followed once additional biomarkers are measured. The current version of the chart is only a prototype and should be further developed to include the detection rate of aggressive PCa, and validated in larger studies.