The use of noble gas isotopes to constrain subsurface fluid flow and hydrocarbon migration in the East Texas Basin

Abstract

The migration of hydrocarbons from source-rock to reservoir is a critical stage in petroleum system evolution. However, as migration occurs along confined pathways over geologically rapid timescales it is challenging to place quantitative constraints on migration behaviour in terms of interaction with other basinal fluids, flux, and lengthscales associated with this process. Due to their inert nature, noble gases are ideal tracers of fluid provenance and physical processes in a variety of subsurface systems, and thus can serve as a potential geochemical indicator of migration distance. The recent proliferation of unconventional hydrocarbon production (i.e., production directly from source-rocks) allows for the analysis of fluids from these strata. Here we present noble gas data from natural gas samples produced from 27 related conventional and unconventional wells within the East Texas basin. These data enable characterisation of fluids during migration from source-rock to conventional reservoir. Unconventional gases and fluids are produced from the Haynesville shale (n = 8), and conventional gases and fluids are sourced from the overlying Cotton Valley (n = 5), Travis Peak (n = 9), and James Lime (n = 5) formations. Samples consist primarily of methane (>70%), with small contributions from longer-chain hydrocarbons, and other gases including CO2 and N2. Atmosphere-derived 36Ar, which is introduced into natural gas accumulations via interaction with groundwater during hydrocarbon generation and migration, is consistently higher in samples that have undergone a greater migration distance from the source interval. Thus, calculated volume ratios of gas-water interaction (Vg/Vw) show a far greater incidence of groundwater interaction in migrated samples. Radiogenically-produced 40Ar is also consistently elevated in migrated samples, despite these reservoirs being located in geologically younger strata. We derive the representative volume of rock required to produce the observed radiogenic 40Ar in each sample and show that samples that have migrated further have acquired radiogenic isotopes from larger volumes of rock. Furthermore, our volumetric parameters derived from atmospheric and radiogenic isotopes are consistent with a simple conceptual model of migration. We quantitatively apply this model to demonstrate that migration occurs along relatively localised pathways. Helium (3He/4He) and argon (40Ar/36Ar) isotopes are correlated and show elevated amounts of mantle-derived 3He and radiogenic 40Ar in migrated samples. We interpret this to represent mixing between a pristine source-rock signature and an endmember characterised by elevated 3He/4He and 40Ar/36Ar, likely representative of mantle-enriched groundwater circulating in the wider hydrogeological basin. Finally, we use an advection-diffusion model to show that enriched mantle 3He in the shallower strata and towards the southern edge of the basin can be explained by influx of mantle helium along the fault-bounded southern edge of the basin over timescales of millions of years. Together these approaches represent the first complete noble gas based characterization of a hydrocarbon system, sampling migration from source-rock to trap. We show conclusively that both atmospheric and radiogenic noble gases are entrained in the hydrocarbon phase during migration and that concentrations scale proportionally with migration distance, as greater volumes of groundwater and host rock are encountered.