“The trip actually opened our eyes to things that we were supposed to do and we were not doing”: developing primary health care system leadership in a low-income country with peer exchanges

Abstract

BackgroundHealth care systems in low and middle-income countries are decentralizing and devolving power to the periphery. Transferring power without systematic processes to develop and nurture leaders at the district compromises the effectiveness and sustainability of the decentralized health system. To address this problem, we developed an approach to leadership learning by observation and experience that improved the organization and performance of the health care system in a district in Ghana.MethodologyUsing two rounds of a longitudinal qualitative study, the study explores the determinants of implementing the Community-Based Health Planning and Services (CHPS) initiative in a district in Ghana. Insights were gained concerning the leadership regimes of two leaders who administered health services in a common geographic area at different points in time with remarkably contrasting outcomes. Insights of health workers who participated in both periods were elicited to clarify interview contexts. Ten focus group discussions (FGDs) and five expert interviews were conducted for each round of the study. The study was informed by a systems appraisal approach that utilized a thematic analytical framework.ResultsProviding district leaders with a practical observational experience had a significant influence on health care delivery in all aspects of health care provision at the district level. Exposing participants to models of best practices facilitated the replication of processes that improved the conduct of service delivery and CHPS implementation. Upon reflection, district leaders attributed performance constraints to their lack of understanding of practical ways of responding to complex district health system development needs. Observation from community members, volunteers, and health workers who witnessed the system development period corroborated narratives that leaders had expressed.ConclusionEffective leadership is optimally developed with participatory learning that provides leaders with direct access to fully functioning systems. Learning by observation can be structured and used to quicken the spread of managerial excellence.