The roots of conflict over US census counts in the late 20th century and prospects for the 21st century

Abstract

Journal of Economic and Social Measurement 31 (2006) 185–205 IOS Press The roots of conflict over US census counts in the late 20 th century and prospects for the 21 st century 1 Paula J. Walashek a and David A. Swanson b,∗ a College of Graduate Business and Management, University of Phoenix, USA of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Mississippi, USA b Department Although not originally intended as such, the US census has become a “Commons” in which private benefits are gained at the expense of public costs. The historical development of the census as a Commons first clearly emerged with the release of the 1970 census results, and since that time contentious litigation over census undercount error has become a standard part of the decennial census landscape. Political battles within the federal government have gone hand-in-hand with these litigation activities. They culminated with a Supreme Court decision on the legality of statistically adjusting census 2000 counts for estimated undercount error. As these battles raged, professional interest in providing methodological fixes for net census undercount error increased while public participation in the census generally declined. This paper examines the history behind these legal battles, the legislative acts, and judicial decisions that led to the 16th Amendment and the loss of the careful balance between public costs and private benefits crafted by the Founding Fathers in Article I of the Constitution. The paper identifies the role that historical actions played in making the census into a Commons, thereby setting the stage for modern day census litigation and other forms of conflict. We observe that as a Commons, the census is facing a potential collapse that cannot be prevented by methodological developments. We conclude by noting that a course of political action may be the best course for preventing such a collapse. Keywords: Census, litigation, Commons, 16 th amendment 1. The Source of Conflict: The Census as Commons In Article I, Section 2, the US Constitution requires Congress to conduct an “actual Enumeration” of the population every ten years “in such Manner as they shall by Law direct.” Accordingly, each decade since 1790, the United States has taken a count of its population – the decennial census. Congress delegated the authority to conduct the decennial census to the Secretary of Commerce in the Census Act. The Secretary, through the Census Bureau, has attempted to answer two important questions: how many people live in the United States and where are these people located? Answers to these questions are important because they determine how many representatives each state is allocated in the federal House of Representatives and 1 An earlier version was presented at the 2004 Hawaii International Conference on Social Sciences. author: David A. Swanson, Department of Sociology and Anthropology, University of Mississippi, University, MS 38677-1848, USA. E-mail: dswanson@olemiss.edu. ∗ Corresponding 0747-9662/06/$17.00  2006 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved