The role of story and place in Indigenous science education: Bigfoot in a youth-designed ecological restoration plan

Abstract

This study explores some of the ways in which the dominant science education system in the United States suppresses Indigenous knowledge systems and privileges Western knowledge. Using anti-oppressive inquiry through critical self-reflection, this study is situated in experiences I have encountered as a non-Indigenous doctoral student, curriculum developer, educator, and budding educational researcher on a 3-year STEM education project with Native youth in two tribal communities in the Pacific Northwest. I describe the cultural tensions experienced between project stakeholders in attempting to plan and implement a culturally-relevant curriculum dominated by Western STEM, and how a pivotal moment in which youth incorporated Bigfoot stories into a stream restoration activity challenged my awareness of this paradox. Therefore, Bigfoot became my teacher in provoking my recognition and appreciation of Indigenous knowledge systems, the role of communal narrative in Indigenous education, and the importance of displacing cognitive imperialism. This study adds to the dialogue that science education must be accessible for diverse learners, including culturally-appropriate and culturally-relevant pedagogies and curriculum, by challenging the status quo of hegemonic knowledge in the dominant system. Indigenous knowledge provides place-specific and contextually meaningful insights about the natural world, which is shortchanged if not provided consideration in its role within science education. As a result, this paper provides a space to consider how acknowledging and accepting diverse knowledge systems as ways of understanding the natural world, including those outside of the dominant system, provides a more holistic and meaningful approach to science education.