The role of seed predation in the maintenance of the Cross Timbers ecotone of Oklahoma, USA

Abstract

I investigated how seed predation differed among tree species and among microhabitats across the Cross Timbers and what that variation may tell us about how this ecotone is maintained. The ecotone is located in Oklahoma, USA, between the eastern deciduous forest and tallgrass prairie where seeds of eight common tree species were placed in three microhabitats (oak forest, tallgrass prairie, and sumac shrub/small-tree/grass mix). After nine days in the field, percent seeds remaining were scored for each of the 120 (8 species×3 microhabitats×5 replicates) dishes. I found for both wind-dispersed tree species, (ash, elm) there was significantly more predation in the prairie microsite, with similar small predation levels in the shrub and forest. For two of the three bird-dispersed species (dogwood, hackberry), there was significantly more predation in the prairie and shrub microsites compared to the forest. Red cedar, however, was not taken by predators very much anywhere. Finally, all three mammal-dispersed tree species (two oaks, pecan) showed significantly more predation in the shrub and forest microsites compared to the prairie. Whereas wind- and bird-dispersed species suffered less predation as microsites became more woody and dark, the dominant oaks showed the opposite trend. Consequently, seed predators are not preventing oaks from advancing across this ecotone, but yearly fluctuations in predator population density, especially in the shrub transitional zone, could be helping to maintain it.