The role of depositional environment and chemical composition on the triple oxygen isotope ratios of ferromanganese precipitates and their endmember components

Abstract

Ferromanganese precipitates - crusts, nodules, and hydrothermal deposits – typically exhibit negative Δ'17O values. These deviations are thought to reflect partial incorporation of dissolved atmospheric O2, a component with strongly negative Δ'17O values, seawater oxygen, and deep sea O2 into Mn-oxide minerals, in combination with the other major mineralogical endmember components (Fe-oxyhydroxide and silicate minerals), and kinetic processes such as oxidation at mineral surfaces and biological respiration. Our understanding of the triple oxygen isotope systematics of these materials are limited, however; in the current body of literature, triple oxygen isotope data has only been generated for marine hydrogenetic (i.e., metals accrete directly from seawater) Fe-Mn crusts and Mn nodules. This study evaluates the underlying chemical and environmental factors contributing to the bulk triple oxygen isotopic composition of Fe-Mn precipitates of different genetic types (i.e., hydrothermal, hydrogenetic, mixed-type) from a variety of formation environments (e.g., volcanic arc, pull-apart basin, hotspot, freshwater lake). To improve our understanding of the triple oxygen isotope systematics of natural Fe-Mn precipitates and better constrain the endmember components, we isolate and measure close approximations of the Mn-oxide, Fe-oxyhydroxide, and silicate fractions. Hydrothermal Fe-Mn deposits show greater variation in δ'18O and Δ'17O values (6.0 to 29.6 ‰ and −0.286 to 0.007 ‰, respectively) than hydrogenetic Fe-Mn crusts (5.1 to 11.9 ‰ and −0.200 to −0.086 ‰, respectively). Lacustrine Mn nodule δ'18O and Δ'17O values (5.1 to 8.8 ‰ and −0.230 to −0.090 ‰, respectively) are similar to marine hydrogenetic Fe-Mn crusts, primarily reflecting tropospheric O2. The triple oxygen isotope ratios of nearly pure Mn-oxide samples cluster into distinct groups based on oxygen source, and mass-balance mixing models suggest a significant proportion of incorporated oxygen was photosynthetic in origin. The layered Fe-Mn precipitates in this study show irregular to rhythmic patterns of δ'18O and Δ'17O values depending on formation environment that mostly do not correlate with Mn, Fe, and Si contents. Shale-normalized rare earth element and yttrium (REYSN) patterns and anomalies (CeSN/CeSN*, EuSN/EuSN*, and YSN/HoSN), which can provide insight on formation conditions (e.g., redox, oxygen fugacity, and REY speciation of fluids), are compared with the triple oxygen isotope data. The REYSN anomalies increase from the bottom to the top of the profile of the layered marine sample, suggesting conditions became more oxic over time. Although the triple oxygen isotope ratios correlate with the Eu anomaly in most Fe-Mn precipitates, hydrothermal input can limit their utility as indicators of oxygen fugacity. The triple oxygen isotope ratios of Fe-Mn precipitates reflect complex processes and mixing of multiple sources. Constraining these oxygen sources will assist future studies in interpreting paleoenvironmental conditions (e.g., the saturation state and triple oxygen isotope ratios of dissolved O2 in bottom water) at the time of Fe-Mn precipitate formation.