The role of consensus and culture in children’s imitation of inefficient actions

Abstract

A significant body of work has demonstrated children’s imitative abilities when learning novel actions. Although some research has examined the role of cultural background in children’s imitation of inefficient actions, to our knowledge no research has explored how culture and conformity interact when engaging in imitation. In Study 1, 87 Caucasian American and Chinese American preschoolers were presented with either one model or three models performing an inefficient action. Whereas there were no cultural differences in imitation in the Single Model condition, Chinese Americans were significantly more likely to copy the model’s preference for an inefficient tool in the Consensus condition. Children’s tool choice was associated with their justification for their choice as well as their memory for the model’s action. Study 2 explored the impact of immigration status on the cultural differences in children’s tool choice by including 16 first-generation Caucasian American children. When comparing the findings with the rates from Study 1, both groups of Caucasian American preschoolers imitated at rates significantly lower than the Chinese American preschoolers. We suggest that the tool choices of Caucasian American children relate to a tendency to engage in a perceptually driven mode of learning, whereas the choices of the Chinese American children reflect a greater likelihood to use a socially driven mode.