The robustness of majority voting compared to filtering misclassified instances in supervised classification tasks

Abstract

Removing or filtering outliers and mislabeled instances prior to training a learning algorithm has been shown to increase classification accuracy, especially in noisy data sets. A popular approach is to remove any instance that is misclassified by a learning algorithm. However, the use of ensemble methods has also been shown to generally increase classification accuracy. In this paper, we extensively examine filtering and ensembling. We examine 9 learning algorithms individually and ensembled together as filtering algorithms as well as the effects of filtering in the 9 chosen learning algorithms on a set of 54 data sets. We compare the filtering results with using a majority voting ensemble. We find that the majority voting ensemble significantly outperforms filtering unless there are high amounts of noise present in the data set. Additionally, for most cases, using an ensemble of learning algorithms for filtering produces a greater increase in classification accuracy than using a single learning algorithm for filtering.