The rise of super (?sub)-specialties courses in psychiatry: Is India ready for it!

Abstract

Byline: N. Manjunatha, Murali. Thyloth, T. Sathyanarayana Rao The field of psychiatry is still growing; [sup][1] however, the phenomenal growth occurred in many areas in the field of Indian psychiatry in last decade. One of them is the increase in postgraduate seats (Diploma in Psychological Medicine (DPM)/Doctor of Medicine (MD)/Diplomate of National Board (DNB) of psychiatry to address the shortage of psychiatrists in our country. In curious latest development two medical institutes in our country started two super-specialties psychiatry courses (after branching out from department of psychiatry) in the academic year of 2011-2012 such as Doctor of Medicine (DM) (Geriatric Mental Health) at 'King George Medical University', Lucknow (http://www.kgmu.org/dept_geriatric.php) and DM (Child and Adolescent Psychiatry) at 'National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences' (NIMHANS), Bangalore (http://www.nimhans.kar.nic.in/cap/default.htm) for candidates of MD/DNB psychiatry. Other awaiting super-specialty psychiatry course is DM (Addiction Medicine) at 'National Drug Dependence Treatment Centre' of 'All India Institute of Medical Sciences', New Delhi and 'Centre for Addiction Medicine', NIMHANS, Bangalore. Debate *In an outlook it is a welcome step, however, authors consider this rise of super-specialties in still growing field of Indian psychiatry is a debatable issue. When our country is already facing 77% average national deficit of psychiatrists, [sup][2] will not this step lead further shortage of general psychiatrists in India? India is currently producing 357 MD (Psychiatry) and 129 Diploma in Psychological Medicine (DPM) per year in various medical college/institutes of our country. [sup][3] Along with these reasons and the migration of qualified psychiatrists to developed countries, will this step be a pragmatic one for MD psychiatry candidates to enter DM in these super-specialties? *Then, what is the need of having super-specialty psychiatric courses? Is there a demand for clinical service, if so, having separate clinic/unit in the psychiatry department (one of the requirement of Medical Council of India (MCI) to start MD psychiatry course) shall be sufficient. Is there a demand in research point of view, if so, developing a separate 3 years course is not justified? If the development for teaching purpose due to lack of expertise, having separate clinic/unit within department of psychiatry would suffice. Considering all above points, Indian academic psychiatry is not ready for premature branching out as 3 years DM course. It may be pragmatic to wait till required number of psychiatrists of India is available for clinical service. *Another important aspect of this development is the employability after their training. Authors tend to believe as not so lucrative for these super-specialties as there are already inadequate practicing general psychiatrists and inadequate teaching psychiatric faculties in medical colleges. *In view of public mental health, when India is struggling to provide primary care psychiatry and facing difficulty in the implementation of 'National Mental Health Program', can we afford to have these super-specialties in psychiatry which further reduces the human resources? Progress in Indian Medical Education with Respect to Super-Specialties Authors feel that the developing new courses with new name are becoming fashionable in the field of Indian education. Medical education of our country is not the exception for this and is already developed new courses in last few decades such as DNB, DM, Magister Chirurgiae (MCh), etc., Irony in this development is having same name (i. …