The relationship between the force applied and perceived by the surgeon during ureteral access sheath placement: ex-vivo experimental model

Abstract

PurposeTo define a peak force of insertion (PFOI) threshold for ureteral damage during ureteral access sheath (UAS) placement on an experimental ureteral orifice model.MethodsA specially designed water tank using 2 laparoscopic 5 mm ports and 2 different size (10 Fr and 8 Fr) sealing cap adaptors (SCA) as ureteral orifices was used to perform the test. A 10–12 Fr UAS was fixed to a load cell and the force of insertion (FOI) was continuously recorded with a digital force gauge.13 experts in the field of endourology who participated performed 3 UAS insertions. The FOI was recorded initially with 10 Fr followed by 8 Fr SCA. On the final insertion, the orifice was obstructed, leaving a 5 cm length to insert the UAS. The experts were asked to “Stop at the point they anticipate ureteral damage, and they would not proceed in real life”.ResultsUsing 10 Fr SCA the PFOI was 2.12 ± 0.58 Newton (N) (range:1.48–3.48) while 8 Fr SCA showed a PFOI 5.76 ± 0.96 N (range:4.05–7.35). Six of the experts, said they would stop proceeding when they reached above 5.1 N. Three experts had PFOI < 5.1 N and the other 4 stated they would go with PFOIs of 5.88, 6.16, 6.69 and 7.35 N when using SCA of 8 Fr.The highest load they would stop proceeding had a PFOI of 6.09 ± 1.87 N (range: 2.53–10.74).ConclusionThe PFOI threshold for ureteral damage inserting UAS of the experts is variable. Although FOI is a subjective perception, experience suggests that ureteral injury may occur at an average of 6.05 N perceived by surgeons’ tactile feedback. In-vivo measurement of UAS PFOI may confirm a threshold.