The relationship between crop size and fruit removal and its implication for the evolution of dioecy

Abstract

The number of fruits removed by birds from individual Ilex opaca (Aquifoliaceae) was found to increase as a function of crop size in both 1986 and 1987. The proportion of the fruit crop removed, however, was not significantly affected by crop size in either year. In 1986 the increase in relative female fitness as a function of crop size rapidly became asymptotic. In 1987 relative female fitness increased more linearly over the range of fruit crop sizes. Differences between years were attributed to differences in disperser abundance. The change in relative fitness with increasing crop size was not sufficient to explain the evolutionary stability of dioecy under conditions such as those in 1986 (i.e., asymptotic fitness gains). Under conditions of more proportional increases in relative fitness (as seen in 1987), circumstances became more favorable for the stability of dioecy, though still not sufficient. This and other empirical studies of the response of avian dispersers to variation in fruit crop size suggest that selection for increased crop size is not likely, by itself, to be strong enough to allow dioecy to exist in a stable state. I suggest that the combined effects of sexual selection (especially through male–male competition) and inbreeding depression will be more important than the effect of differential dispersal success for the evolution and maintenance of dioecy in plants. Key words: dioecy, dispersal, frugivore, holly, Ilex.