The reaction between some dyes and synthetic hydroxyapatite. 2. Nature of the binding reaction.

Abstract

In order to study the reactions involved in some of the histochemical procedures used for demonstrating calcium in calcified tissues, it was considered appropriate to use well characterized synthetic hydroxyapatite in the first instance. In the first paper of this series (Speirs, 1970), it was found that many dyes not previously used in histochemistry were capable of staining hydroxyapatite; the purpose of the present paper is to describe the numerous experimental approaches that have been made in an attempt to elucidate the mechanisms involved in the adsorption of some of these dyes by hydroxyapatite. Dyes have been grouped according to their adsorption curves (in which dye uptake by solid was plotted against the concentration of dye in solution at equilibrium). From these graphs, predictions and calculations were made concerning the orientation of the dye molecules on the surface of hydroxyapatite, the type of bonding possibly involved and the area of surface covered by each molecule. These were then related to the dimensions and structure of the dye molecules. Saturation of surface sites was achieved in the adsorption of some dyes and the nature of these sites was investigated by studying (1) competition between several dyes for the surface, (2) the accessibility of surface calcium and phosphorus in stained and unstained hydroxyapatite, and (3) the release of32P from surface labelled hydroxyapatite during dye adsorption. Most of the dyes adsorbed from 95% ethanol were displaced relatively easily by treatment with 0.5 mM phosphate in ethanol, but those adsorbed from tris buffer, pH 7.45, were more stable when exposed to phosphate in tris. Treatment of stained hydroxyapatite with solvents containing 0.5 mM calcium reduced the rate of elution of the dyes. Convincing evidence for chelation, hydrogen bonding, ion exchange and physical adsorption processes as the mechanisms of adsorption has not been obtained. Future studies to investigate these processes are discussed.