The problem of the last bed: Contextualization and a new simulation framework for analyzing physician decisions

Abstract

Faced with a full Intensive Care Unit (ICU), physicians need to decide between turning away a new patient in need of critical care and creating a vacancy by prematurely discharging a current occupant. This dilemma is widely discussed in the medical literature, where the influencing factors are identified, the patient discharge process described and the patient health consequences analyzed. Nevertheless, the existing mathematical models of ICU management practices overlook many of the factors considered by physicians in real-world triage decisions.This paper offers a review of the medical and mathematical literature on patient discharge decisions, and a proposal for a new simulation framework to enable more realistic mathematical modeling of the real-world patient discharge process. Our model includes a) the times at which discharge decisions are made and setup times for patient transfer from the ICU to a general ward and preparation of an ICU bed for an incoming patient, in order to capture the impossibility of an immediate switch of patients; b) advance notice of the number of patients due to arrive from elective surgery requiring intensive postoperative care and potentially triggering the need for early discharges to avoid surgery cancelations; and c) patient health status (to reflect the dependency of physicians’ discharge decisions on health indicators) by modeling length of stay with a phase-type distribution in which a medical meaning is assigned to each state.A simulation-based optimization method is also proposed as a means to obtain optimal discharge decisions as a function of the health status of current patients, the bed occupancy level and the number of planned arrivals from elective surgery over the following days. Optimal decisions should strike a balance between patient rejection and LoS reduction.This new simulation framework generates an optimal discharge policy, which closely resembles real decision-making under a cautious discharge policy, where the frequency of early discharge increases with the ICU occupancy level. This is a contrast with previous simulation models, which consider only the triage of the last bed, disregarding the pressures on physicians faced with high bed occupancy levels.