THE PROBLEM OF PLOIDY IN ECHEVERIA (CRASSULACEAE) II. TETRAPLOIDY IN E. SECUNDA

Abstract

Every chromosome number from n = 12 to n =34 and also many higher numbers are known in one or more of the 130+ species of Echeveria, and the numerical boundary between diploids and tetraploids is not immediately apparent. Echeveria also is extraordinary for the number and diversity of hybrids that it can produce in cultivation, both within the genus and with species of several related genera. In 42 collections studied, the morphologically and cytologically variable E. secunda of central Mexico has n = 30‐32, often with one or more B‐chromosomes, and some quadrivalents are formed at meiosis in nearly every cell. Twenty‐four hybrids of E. secunda, with 22 species or cytotypes considered diploids, resemble the former much more closely in appearance, and at meiosis 15‐16 paired elements (bivalents and multivalents) are formed, never more, regardless of the number of chromosomes, 12 to 34, that were received from the other parent. It is concluded that the 15‐16 paired elements in these hybrids are formed by the 30‐32 chromosomes received from E. secunda, and that most chromosomes from the other parents occur as univalents, although usually a few associate with pairs from E. secunda to produce multivalents. Hybrids of E. secunda with 11 definitely tetraploid species having n = 34 to n = 68 are nicely intermediate in morphology between their parents, form mostly or entirely bivalents at meiosis, and most, probably all, including five intergeneric hybrids, are fertile. These observations are all consistent with the conclusion that E. secunda is an autotetraploid, even though no plants of the species having n = 15 or 16 have been found, and even though some other species of Echeveria having as many as 34 gametic chromosomes appear to be effectively diploid. Observations on pollen stainability and on second‐generation hybrids are all compatible with this conclusion. The high chromosome numbers in many Mexican Crassulaceae that are now effectively diploid may have originated as polyploids that have become diploidized by mutation, loss, or suppression of duplicated chromosomes, segments, and genes. Hybrids of E. secunda, with three other species that appear to be tetraploids, have less regular meiosis, apparently because all of the chromosomes from the other parents do not regularly form pairs in the hybrids. These three species may represent intermediate stages in the processes of diploidization.