The pre-operative stratification of patients with colorectal liver metastases: Computed tomography arterial portography (CTAP) has no added value

Abstract

Aims The purpose of this study was to determine if Computed Tomography Arterial Portography (CTAP) has additional value to Contrast Enhanced helical CT (CE-CT) in selecting patients for hepatic surgery or Isolated Hepatic Perfusion/systemic chemotherapy. Materials and methods Forty-one patients were included. All CT's were performed in the normal pre-operative work-up of patients with liver metastases in our regular clinical setting and reviewed blinded by a radiologist. For CE-CT and CTAP the number, size (largest diameter) and location of all suspected malignant liver lesions were recorded. The favourable treatment option was determined based on the results of CE-CT and CTAP independently. The therapeutic decision based on CE-CT and CTAP was compared with the definite treatment. For all patients with recorded findings during surgery, consisting of intra-operative ultrasound, liver palpation and histology a standard of reference for lesion detection was available. For these patients detection rates and the fraction of false positive lesions were calculated. Results Twenty-seven patients were treated with hepatic resection and/or RFA. Fourteen patients were treated with chemotherapy, 4 with Isolated Hepatic Perfusion (IHP) and 10 with systemic therapy. Based on the findings on CE-CT 31 patients were classified as surgical candidates and 10 as non-surgical patients. Based on the findings on CTAP, surgery should be the treatment of choice in 29 patients and 12 patients were classified non-surgical. CE-CT and CTAP disagreed in two cases (4.9%). Seventy-four metastases were identified at surgery and pathologically proved. CE-CT and CTAP showed 53 (.72) and 66 (.89) metastases, respectively. Conclusion Despite a significantly higher detection rate for hepatic metastases, CTAP has no added value in the therapeutic stratification in candidates for resection of hepatic metastases of colorectal cancer.