The occurrence of a flagship raptor species in intensive agroecosystems is associated with more diverse farmland bird communities: Opportunities for market-based conservation

Abstract

Traditional livestock systems have supported farmland biodiversity for millennia. However, modern intensive husbandry is challenging wildlife persistence in agroecosystems. We assessed the multiscale determinants of the species richness of breeding bird communities, as well as the occurrence of a flagship raptor species, the lesser kestrel Falco naumanni, in an intensive agroecosystem mostly dedicated to the production of the world-renowned Parmigiano Reggiano cheese. We relied on three avian community richness metrics reflecting a gradient of increasing association with farmed landscapes, i.e. the overall breeding bird species richness, the richness of farmland species, and the richness of ground-nesters (i.e. species that mostly breed within crops) and tested their association with the landscape, agricultural, and pedological variables as well as with lesser kestrel occurrence. We showed that environmental variables determining overall richer avian assemblages did not coincide with those shaping farmland and ground-nesting species richness, thus challenging the potential effectiveness of conservation actions. However, such actions could be optimized by taking into account different spatial scales affecting different species groups. Indeed, landscape heterogeneity, semi-natural/marginal habitats, and a moderate cover of build-up areas enhanced overall species richness at a small spatial scale. At a broader scale, landscape heterogeneity enhanced farmland species richness, whereas fragmentation determined by urbanization negatively affected ground-nesters. Avian community richness metrics were maximized at an intermediate cover of three prevailing crops (winter, summer, and hay crops), increasing when they co-occurred, i.e., in the presence of crop rotation. Lesser kestrel occurrence was associated with richer assemblages of ground-nesting species because this raptor and ground-nesters showed analogous ecological requirements. These findings suggest that the lesser kestrel can be regarded as an ideal flagship for market-based conservation initiatives (e.g., tailored to the production of biodiversity-friendly agri-food products) in intensive agroecosystems since actions aimed at improving the foraging habitats of the species are likely to benefit co-occurring farmland birds of conservation interest.