The new emergency department “Tuscan triage System”. Validation study

Abstract

IntroductionA new organizational framework was recently implemented in Tuscan Emergency Departments (EDs), including specific low-priority streaming. A new ED triage system, named “Tuscan Triage System” (TTS), was devised with the purpose of applying this reorganization. MethodsA validation study was designed with the primary aims of assessing the content, face, and criterion validities, and the inter-rater reliability of the TTS. The secondary aim was to estimate the differences in triage level assignation between the previous “Regional Triage System” (RTS) and the TTS. Twenty-four nurses trained for the TTS were enrolled to assign TTS priority levels to 100 triage clinical case vignettes drawn up by the developers of the TTS (reference standard). ResultsThe Content Validity Index – Scale/Average (S-CVI/Ave) of TTS was 0.98. Concerning to face validity, the S-CVI/Ave was 1. The highest adherence of triage level assignation to the reference standard was for levels 1 and 2. The Krippendorff α value was 0.808. Undertriage and overtriage were 10.45% and 14.29%, respectively. Overall, the comparation between RTS and TTS showed a marked shift of level assignation towards TTS low priority levels. ConclusionsThe TTS seems to be safe. These results should be confirmed through studies in the real clinical settings.