Abstract
Abstract Recent attention to the role of Indigenous knowledge (IK) in environmental monitoring, research and decision‐making is likely to attract new people to this field of work. Advancing the bringing together of IK and science in a way that is desirable to IK holders can lead to successful and inclusive research and decision‐making. We used the Delphi technique with 18 expert participants who were IK holders or working closely with IK from across the Arctic to examine the drivers of progress and limitations to the use of IK along with science to inform decision‐making related to wildlife, reindeer herding and the environment. We also used this technique to identify participants' experiences of scientists' misconceptions concerning IK. Participants had a strong focus on transformative change relating to the structure of institutions, politics, rights, involvement, power and agency over technical issues advancing or limiting progress (e.g. new technologies and language barriers). Participants identified two modes of desirable research: coproducing knowledge with scientists and autonomous Indigenous‐led research. They highlighted the need for more collaborative and coproduction projects to allow further refinement of approaches and more funding to support autonomous, Indigenous‐led research. Most misconceptions held by scientists concerning IK that were identified by participants related to the spatial, temporal and conceptual scope of IK, and the perceived need to validate IK using Western science. Our research highlights some of the issues that need to be addressed by all participants in research and decision‐making involving IK and science. While exact approaches will need to be tailored to specific social‐ecological contexts, consideration of these broader concerns revealed by our analysis are likely to be central to effective partnerships. A free Plain Language Summary can be found within the Supporting Information of this article.
Highlights
There is growing recognition of the need to engage with and utilize Indigenous knowledge (IK) in a more comprehensive and meaningful way when conducting assessments of environmental change and making environmental decisions from local to global scales (Ford, Cameron, et al, 2016; Ford, Maillet, et al, 2016; Gustafsson, Berg, Lidskog, & Löfmarck, 2019; Obermeister, 2019)
We used the Delphi technique with 18 expert participants who were IK holders or working closely with IK from across the Arctic to examine the drivers of progress and limitations to the use of IK along with science to inform decision-making related to wildlife, reindeer herding and the environment
Our research highlights a range of factors that external parties need to be cognizant of when working with IK to inform decision-making
Summary
There is growing recognition of the need to engage with and utilize Indigenous knowledge (IK) in a more comprehensive and meaningful way when conducting assessments of environmental change and making environmental decisions from local to global scales (Ford, Cameron, et al, 2016; Ford, Maillet, et al, 2016; Gustafsson, Berg, Lidskog, & Löfmarck, 2019; Obermeister, 2019). Several factors underlie the benefits of including IK in natural resource management These include a strong link between cultural and biological diversity inherent within IK systems, the timescales and temporal grain over which these knowledge systems operate and their holistic view of systems and the opportunity to address social justice issues through the inclusion of IK in research and decision-making (Bohensky & Maru, 2011; Gavin et al, 2015). Biocultural approaches may thereby provide frameworks for integrating IK and science (Mackey & Claudie, 2015) This approach claims that by working within the relevant local system of values and cultural context, more favourable outcomes for biological systems that address community needs can be achieved (Davidson-Hunt et al, 2012)
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Sign-in/Register to access full text options 
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
