The nature of the salt error in the Sn(II)-reduced molybdenum blue reaction for determination of dissolved reactive phosphorus in saline waters

Abstract

Sn(II) is a well-known reductant used in the formation of phosphomolybdenum blue for the determination of dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) in waters because it provides rapid and quantitative reduction. However, in saline waters, this method suffers from a salt error which causes a significant decrease in sensitivity. This phenomenon has never been adequately explained in the literature. The Murphy and Riley method, which uses Sb(III) and ascorbic acid for the reduction step, is preferred for DRP determination in saline waters because it is unaffected by salinity, but it exhibits a sensitivity approximately 30% lower than that when Sn(II) is used as the reductant without Cl− interference. This study investigates the processes causing the salt error and possible ways of minimizing it, so that the benefits of Sn(II) reduction on the molybdenum blue reaction rate and sensitivity may be exploited in the determination of low levels of DRP in marine and estuarine waters. It has been established that the salt error is caused by the formation of Sn(IV) chloro-complexes which compete with the formation of Sn(IV)-substituted phosphomolybdenum blue, forcing the reaction to proceed via the much slower, less favourable process of direct reduction that occurs in methods using organic reductants such as ascorbic acid.