The most common causes and effects of technical debt

Abstract

Background: The presence of technical debt (TD) brings risks to a software project and makes it difficult to manage. Several TD management strategies have been proposed, but considering actions that could explicitly prevent the insertion of TD in the first place and monitor its effects is not yet a common practice. Thus, while TD management is an important topic, it is also worthwhile to understand the causes that could lead development teams to incur different types of debt as well as the effects of their presence on software projects. Aims: The objective of this work is twofold. First, we investigate the state of practice in the TD area including the status quo, the causes that lead to TD occurrence, and the effects of existing TD. Second, we present the design of InsighTD, a globally distributed family of industrial surveys on causes and effects of TD, and the results of its first execution. Method: We designed the InsighTD in joint collaboration with several TD researchers. It is designed to run as an incremental large scale study based on continuous and independent replications of the questionnaire in different countries. Results: This paper presents the first results of the first execution of the survey. In total, 107 practitioners from the Brazilian software industry answered the questionnaire. Results indicate that there is a broad familiarity with the concept of TD. Deadlines, inappropriate planning, lack of knowledge, and lack of a well-defined process are among the top 10 cited and most likely causes that lead to the occurrence of TD. On the other side, low quality, delivery delay, low maintainability, rework and financial loss are among the top 10 most commonly cited and impactful effects of TD. Conclusion: With InsighTD, we intend to reduce the problem of isolated investigations in TD that are not yet representative and, thus, build a continuous and generalizable empirical basis for understanding practical problems and challenges of TD.