The Manchester Large Macular Hole Study: Is it Time to Reclassify Large Macular Holes?

Abstract

To evaluate anatomic and functional outcomes of full-thickness macular holes (FTMH) larger than 400μm following vitrectomy, internal limiting membrane peel, gas tamponade, and face-down posturing. A retrospective interventional case series. A total of 258 consecutive eyes with FTMH larger than 400μm were enrolled at the Manchester Royal Eye Hospital study over a 5-year period from 2012 to 2017. All eyes underwent pars plana vitrectomy, ILM peel, and gas tamponade. Anatomic success rates were measured. A correlation between macular hole size and closure was evaluated. A total of 258 eyes were analyzed. The anatomic closure rate was 89.92%. When divided into quartiles, the closure rate of FTMH was 98% (64/65) in the 400-477μm quartile, 91% (59/65) in the 478-558μm quartile, 94% (60/64) in the 559-649μm quartile, and 76% (49/64) in the 650-1416μm quartile. Using receiver operating characteristic and area under the curve analysis, the maximum sensitivity and specificity was obtained with a cutoff ≤ 630μm (sensitivity 76.7%, specificity 69.2%) giving a Youden index (J) of 0.46. One hundred and forty-six eyes (56.6%) improved by 0.3 logMAR units from their preoperative best-corrected visual acuity at 3months following surgery. This study shows that standard FTMH surgical repair has very high success rate up to 650μm. It may suggest that there is a need for a reclassification of large FTMH, and new surgical techniques such as internal limiting membrane flaps should be reserved for macular holes larger than 650μm.