The Late-Paleoarchean Ultra-Depleted Commondale Komatiites: Earth's Hottest Lavas and Consequences for Eruption

Abstract

Abstract The c.3·3 Ga Commondale komatiites located south of the Barberton greenstone belt in the Kaapvaal Craton are different from other komatiites, possessing compositional and textural features unique to this occurrence. Unlike almost all other known komatiite occurrences, they are not associated with komatiitic basalts or basalts. The komatiite flows are 0·5–25 m thick and are made up of a marginal zone of spinifex-textured and fine-grained aphyric rocks (low-Mg group) and an inner zone of olivine cumulates (high-Mg group), arranged in such a way to give highly symmetrical compositional profiles for many flows. Olivine is the dominant phase in all rocks, but orthopyroxene occurs as spinifex and elongate laths in the marginal zone. Clinopyroxene and plagioclase are entirely absent. The olivine cumulates formed from Mg-rich magma (36·1% MgO, 6·8% FeO) which caused inflation of the thicker flows. The maximum observed olivine composition in cores (Fo 96·6) is the highest recorded for any komatiite worldwide. The high-Mg magma would have erupted at a temperature close to 1670°C, the highest inferred temperature for an anhydrous terrestrial lava. The marginal zone is enriched in incompatible elements compared with the inner zone and formed by fractionation of the parental melt. However, all rock-types in the marginal zone are depleted in FeO (some as low as 3·5%) which could not have been derived by any primary magmatic process. The marginal zone rocks were modified by assimilation and/or alteration by seawater (or brine) components causing migration of iron and strong enrichment of sodium (up to 1·6 wt % Na2O) and chlorine (up to 2400 ppm). Zirconium has an identical distribution to sodium, with both elements greatly enriched above what would result from fractional crystallization, and may result from speciation of these elements at high temperature followed by post-crystallization alteration. Rare earth elements, Y and Nb have contents commensurate with fractionation of the primitive parental magma. Dendritic-textured olivine-rich rocks with orthopyroxene spinifex spatially and compositionally transitional between the marginal zone and the olivine cumulates resulted from interaction of the high temperature parental magma in the centre of the flows with the fractionated melt at the flow margins. A further manifestation of this association is the development of highly regular fine-scale (5–15 cm) layering (up to 45 layers) of alternating olivine cumulate and spinifex near the base of thick flows. This is overlain by olivine cumulates in which the melt/crystal-mush became arranged into a 3-dimensional network controlled by re-distribution of the trapped melt manifest by a spectacular knobbly texture in outcrop. Over 200 flow units are recognized and detailed chemical and mineralogical studies were carried out on drill cores intersecting 375 m of stratigraphy. The parental magma was highly depleted (in ppm Nb 0·017, Zr 1·18, total REE 1·7 and Gd/YbN=0·3, La/YbN=0·038) and although generally regarded to fall into the rare category of Al-enriched komatiites (AEKs), it is considered that these lavas are a unique class of their own of ultra-depleted komatiites. Relative to other AEKs the Commondale komatiites are both enriched in Al as well as being markedly depleted in Ti (390 ppm), giving rise to the extremely high Al2O3/TiO2 (81). The high temperature and low viscosity of the magma resulted in emplacement processes previously unrecognized in komatiites. The primary melt was derived by melting of mantle peridotite in equilibrium with olivine and orthopyroxene. The initial source was depleted in incompatible elements by small degrees of melting (3–4%) followed by high degrees of partial melting (70%) of the subsequent refractory source at 5 GPa (∼150 km).