The key elements of traceability in chemical measurement: agreed or still under debate?

Abstract

Talking about “traceability” means talking about a “property of the result of a measurement”, about “the value of a standard”, about “stated references” and about an “unbroken chain of comparisons”. It describes by which comparison, and to which other value, the result of a measurement has been obtained, i.e. is “traceable to”. It is about the underlying structure of the measurement process of the result of a measurement and therefore about the authority of the result. Since values carried by (certified) reference materials have also been obtained by measurement, the definition of traceability equally applies. Traceability in the context of reference materials is also about the authority of the values carried by the (certified) reference materials and is, therefore, of key importance for the authority of the reference materials themselves. Hence, values of results of measurements constitute part of the traceability chain and their uncertainties are an intrinsic accompanying phenomenon. Uncertainties need a traceability chain against which they can be evaluated, and a traceability chain is an a priori requirement for evaluating the uncertainty budget of a measurement result. An attempt has been made to exemplify “traceability” chains in some types of chemical measurement and to identify the degree of international agreement on the key elements of “traceability”. It is concluded that there is less than universal agreement on this issue. The debate should continue in order to arrive at the international understanding and agreement needed, as “traceability” is now being incorporated in the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), the International Laboratory Accreditation Co-operation (ILAC) and in other “guiding” or regulatory documents. It is also the reason why the Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM) has taken up the study of the concept in its core programme on Metrology in Chemistry, and why it sponsored the Workshop in Bratislava.