The Karyotypes of Diploid Cespitose Zinnias: A Method and Analysis

Abstract

The karyotypes of the three diploid (n = 10) species of the subg. Diplothrix (Zinnia—Compositae) were compared to determine whether there were any demonstrable differences which could then be sought in their polyploid derivatives. Because many of the chromosomes in a set were too similar to distinguish confidently between them, a method of analysis was developed which measures the similarity of whole sets of chromosomes rather than individual ones. The method consists of measuring the distances between graph-plotted vertices representing arm lengths of chromosomes of real or paper hybrids and then comparing these distances by means of U tests with those similarly derived for the “parents.” This procedure obviates the need of attempting to identify morphologues (morphologically similar chromosomes) in a somatic diploid root-tip cell and to equate corresponding pairs of chromosomes from different cells of a single plant or from different species or hybrids. No demonstrable differences in the karyotypes of diploid cespitose zinnias were found. Analysis of previously published data by this method indicated that there has been a general non-objectivity and non-operationalism in the determination of homologous chromosomes, and a general but unwarranted assumption that morphologues are in reality genologues (genetically corresponding chromosomes).