The intrasession repeatability of pattern electroretinograms and the effects of digital filtering

Abstract

Transient pattern electroretinograms were recorded in 12 normal young volunteers with the use of 12' and 30' checkerboard stimuli and 1 c/deg and 2.5 c/deg vertical gratings. The intrasession repeatability of pattern electroretinograms was determined by employing alternative statistics to the frequently used correlation coefficients. Comparisons were made with the repeatability of cone electroretinograms elicited by ganzfeld stimulation. The coefficient of repeatability was substantially lower (better) for pattern electroretinogram b-wave implicit times than for a-wave implicit times and b-wave amplitudes, the latter having high coefficients of repeatability. Cone electroretinograms had better repeatability with respect to all three parameters. Digital filtering using a bandpass of 1-40 Hz was applied to the original pattern electroretinograms recorded with a bandpass of 1-250 Hz. Although peak definition was generally enhanced, repeatability did not show marked improvement. Differences between broadband analogue-filtered pattern electroretinograms and the same responses with high-frequency noise removed by digital filtering need to be taken into account. The coefficient of repeatability statistic appears to facilitate the assessment of pattern electroretinograms and permits the comparison of the repeatability of both implicit time and amplitude parameters irrespective of absolute values. The implications of the relatively poor repeatability of pattern electroretinogram b-wave amplitudes for clinical applications need to be considered.