The influence of target-masker similarity on across-ear interference in dichotic listening

Abstract

In most dichotic listening tasks, the comprehension of a target speech signal presented in one ear is unaffected by the presence of irrelevant speech in the opposite ear. However, recent results have shown that contralaterally presented interfering speech signals do influence performance when a second interfering speech signal is present in the same ear as the target speech. In this experiment, we examined the influence of target-masker similarity on this effect by presenting ipsilateral and contralateral masking phrases spoken by the same talker, a different same-sex talker, or a different-sex talker than the one used to generate the target speech. The results show that contralateral target-masker similarity has the greatest influence on performance when an easily segregated different-sex masker is presented in the target ear, and the least influence when a difficult-to-segregate same-talker masker is presented in the target ear. These results indicate that across-ear interference in dichotic listening is not directly related to the difficulty of the segregation task in the target ear, and suggest that contralateral maskers are least likely to interfere with dichotic speech perception when the same general strategy could be used to segregate the target from the masking voices in the ipsilateral and contralateral ears.