The induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes: II. Temporal and dose response relationships of tolerance induction in B lymphocytes of various differentiation states

Abstract

The induction of TNP-specific B lymphocyte tolerance by TNBS in sources representing various differentiation states was studied in an adoptive cell transfer system. An adoptive assay was utilized in which the delay of immunization with the T-independent antigen TNP-LPS resulted in an enhanced PFC response. TNBS induced tolerance in spleen cells which was independent of T cell activity, was dose dependent, and could be adoptively transferred. While bone marrow and spleen cells were susceptible to tolerogenesis after cell transfer, TNBS treatment of the donor induced unresponsiveness in splenocytes but not marrow cells. The tolerance dose response relationship and the effect of the temporal relationship between cell transfer and tolerogenesis were studied in B lymphocytes from various sources. Adult spleen cells were resistant to tolerance induction late in the adoptive response, and the tolerance induced by TNBS administration 1 hr after cell transfer was dose dependent. Athymic nude spleen cells and adult bone marrow cells displayed similar characteristics while fetal liver cells were somewhat more susceptible to the induction of unresponsiveness. Neonatal spleen cells were rendered tolerant at much lower doses and at any stage of the adoptive response. The hierarchy obtained in these studies in the order of decreasing resistance to tolerance induction is: adult normal and athymic nude spleen and adult bone marrow, fetal liver, and neonatal spleen. This variation in tolerogenesis appears to be due to the maturity of the cell types which may reflect differences in B lymphocyte sub-populations.