The importance of incorporating rain intensity profiles in rainfall simulation studies of infiltration, runoff production, soil erosion, and related landsurface processes

Abstract

The temporal sequence of fluctuating rainfall intensities during an event - the intensity profile or 'rainfall pattern' - is known to affect water partitioning at the ground surface and associated erosional processes. There can be large differences in runoff ratios and runoff rates between early-peak and late-peak events, and hence in the depth, speed, and sediment transport capacity of resulting overland flow. Whilst rainfall intensity may fluctuate continually during all IPs in natural rainfall, there is little information on the rates of such intensity fluctuations that can be used to guide the design of rainfall simulation experiments. This review analyses relevant data derived from published high-resolution rainfall records and also from new analyses of data from Australian ground observing stations. Both sources confirm the occurrence of rates of intensity change of greater than 500 mm h−1 min−1. It is suggested that the fluctuating intensities characteristic of natural rainfall need to be employed in rainfall simulation experiments in order to generate results applicable to natural landsurface processes like infiltration or soil removal. Constant-intensity rain, as commonly used in rainfall simulation experiments, lacks both the kinds of rapid intensity fluctuations seen in natural rainfall, as well as any representation of natural intensity profiles. These unrepresentative conditions can result in lower runoff rates and larger proportions of infiltration than when intensity fluctuations are present. There is thus a strong case for changing the design of rainfall simulation to reflect more closely natural intensity fluctuations and intensity profiles and their influence on key surface processes such as overland flow and soil erosion.