The impact of regional landscape context on local maladaptive trait divergence: a field test using freshwater copepod acid tolerance

Abstract

Theoretical work has shown that spatial landscape context can contribute to reducing local adaptation in populations depending on the spatial pattern of environmental heterogeneity, the spatial scale of distances between habitats on landscapes, and the level of habitat connectivity. However, only a handful of empirical studies have addressed the impact of regional landscape context on local trait divergence in natural populations. We tested if local adaptation in abiotic tolerance is diminished in landscapes with strong spatial heterogeneity and habitat proximity. We used a freshwater copepod (Leptodiaptomus minutus) that is known to show local adaptive divergence in acid tolerance as a study system to understand the effects of regional landscape-level spatial heterogeneity in lake/pond pH on local trait divergence. We compared local divergence in copepod acid tolerance from three types of landscapes: (i) a homogeneous pH landscape of exclusively circumneutral lakes (pH ≥ 6.0); (ii) a heterogeneous pH landscape with a mixture of acidic and circumneutral lakes; and (iii) a heterogeneous pH landscape in which relatively infrequent circumneutral ponds are embedded in a predominantly acidic landscape. We found that local adaptation to circumneutral lake/pond pH was most reduced in the pH-heterogeneous landscape dominated by acidic habitats, likely because of gene flow from surrounding nearby acidic ponds. Our study empirically confirms theoretical predictions that spatial landscape context is important for explaining regional differences in population environmental tolerances. These effects may become important for understanding regional differences in population fitness trade-offs when presented in combination with multiple stressors.