The Honey Bee Colony's Criterion for Candidate Selection: "Ongoing" or "One-Shot"?

Abstract

In the honey bee, the queen's death severely threatens the survival of the colony. In an emergency, new queens are reared from young worker larvae, where nepotism is thought to influence the choice of queen candidates by the workers. This article simulates the emergency queen-rearing process in a colony under natural conditions and records the results of colony selection (without nepotism). In queenless colonies, worker larvae aged three days or younger were preferred for queen rearing, and 1-day-old larvae were the first to be selected for the queen-cell cups. In the capping stage, the number of capped queen cells selected from the 1-day-old larvae was much higher than the 3-day-old larvae. On the first day, the number of emerging queens reared from 1-day-old larvae was significantly higher than the queens reared from 2-day-old and 3-day-old larvae. However, there was no significant difference in the birth weights of queens reared from 1-day-old, 2-day-old, or 3-day-old larvae. When the newly emerged queens were introduced into the original queenless colony, 1-day-old larval queens triggered more worker followers than 2-day-old larval queens. The expression of ovarian development-related genes (vg, hex110, and Jh) was higher in queens reared from 1-day-old larvae than those reared from 2-day-old and 3-day-old larvae, indicating that the quality of the queens reared from 1-day-old larvae is superior. This study shows that in the absence of nepotism, the colony selection of queen candidates at the larval stage, capping stage, and emerging stage is not final, but is gradually optimized to maximize colony development through a "quality control" process.