The great art of government: Locke's use of consent

Abstract

That government should be rooted in consent of governed may be most accepted aspect of John Locke's liberal theory. Yet to this day Lockeans have reached no consensus over what constitutes consent or whether Locke even intended consent to be a standard of legitimacy. Peter Josephson now takes a close look at Locke's writings on both consent and art of governance to show how each informs other. Moving beyond previous scholarship, he gives us a Locke as much concerned with effective functioning of government as with roots of its moral legitimacy. According to Josephson, if we wish to understand the great art of government, as one of founders of modern liberalism presents it, we must examine principle and practice of consent in Locke's political scheme. In examining foundation of Locke's political theory, Josephson explores ways in which Locke's government by consent can coexist with preservation of law of nature or reason. As Josephson shows, Locke argues that reasonable customs can bridge divide between will of people and rule of reason. Josephson's work makes important new contributions to understanding Lockean thought. In particular, he shows how Locke joins normative theory with a practical concern for art of effective government. He also argues that Lockean liberalism is not neutral with regard to conceptions of virtue, character, or good life: indeed, liberal regime requires virtues of toleration, civility, and industriousness in order to succeed and must teach its subjects those virtues in order to preserve that regime. While others have variously branded Locke's philosophy as majoritarian, aristocratic, or monarchist, Josephson cuts through these disputes to present a previously unrevealed Locke. His meticulous study pays keen attention to details of Locke's works, while reconciling many of disparate and often confusing features of Lockean thought. In sum, it offers serious readers a richer, deeper, and more nuanced understanding of this formative thinker and liberalism he inspired.