Abstract

As manta rays face increased threats from targeted and bycatch fisheries, manta ray watching tourism, if managed properly, may present an attractive economic alternative to consumptive use of these species. Both species in the genus Manta (Manta alfredi and Manta birostris) are classified by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature Red List as species Vulnerable to extinction in the wild, and are considered unsustainable as fisheries resources due to their conservative life history characteristics, which considerably reduce their ability to recover population numbers when depleted. Utilising dive operator surveys, Internet research, and a literature review, this study provides the first global estimate of the direct economic impact of manta ray watching tourism and examines the potential socio-economic benefits of non-consumptive manta ray watching operations relative to consumptive use of manta rays as a fishery resource. In the 23 countries in which manta ray watching operations meeting our criteria were identified, we estimated direct revenue to dive operators from manta ray dives and snorkels at over US$73 million annually and direct economic impact, including associated tourism expenditures, of US$140 million annually. Ten countries account for almost 93% of the global revenue estimate, specifically Japan, Indonesia, the Maldives, Mozambique, Thailand, Australia, Mexico, United States, Federated States of Micronesia and Palau. In many of the areas where directed fisheries for manta rays are known to occur, these activities overlap with manta ray tourism sites or the migratory range of the mantas on which these sites depend, and are likely to be unsustainable and detrimental to manta ray watching tourism.

Highlights

  • While some conservation biologists assert that the intrinsic value of nature should provide sufficient ethical justification for its conservation [1,2,3], environmental policy decision makers are challenged with balancing the needs of numerous stakeholders amid increasing competition for the use of valuable and diminishing natural resources [4]

  • In light of the threats that exist to these animals, this study aims to provide the first global estimate of the direct economic impact of manta ray watching tourism and examine the potential socioeconomic benefits of non-consumptive manta ray watching operations relative to consumptive use of manta rays as a fishery resource

  • While we only considered in-country expenditures to estimate direct economic impact per country, considering the remote locations of most manta watching locations, it is likely that a large proportion of manta ray watching tourists travel long distances, and international travel expenses not included in this analysis may contribute substantially to economic impact globally

Read more

Summary

Introduction

While some conservation biologists assert that the intrinsic value of nature should provide sufficient ethical justification for its conservation [1,2,3], environmental policy decision makers are challenged with balancing the needs of numerous stakeholders amid increasing competition for the use of valuable and diminishing natural resources [4]. Marine species involved in such activities range from whales, to turtles, to seals, to sharks and rays, and interactions range from observing these animals from a boat or from shore to in water dive and snorkel experiences [10,11,12,13,14,15] These activities have expanded, becoming increasingly popular since the 1980s [7,10,16,17], and have been shown to generate significant economic benefits, both in their own right and to the supporting businesses within the local economies in which they operate [5,18,19,20]. Manta ray interactions are proving to be a highly sought-after experience for divers and snorkelers [11,24,25,26], with tourists in the Maldives willing to pay more for excursions involving mantas than either sharks or turtles [27], and the number of visitors on tours to see manta rays surpassing those looking for whale sharks in Western Australia’s Bateman Bay on Ningaloo Reef [25]

Objectives
Methods
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call