The evolution of multiqueen breeding in eusocial lineages with permanent physically differentiated castes

Abstract

The hypothesis that obligate eusociality always evolved from ancestral states of strict lifetime monogamy implies that (1) facultatively eusocial lineages had to abandon multifemale breeding to achieve permanent morphologically differentiated castes, and (2) lineages of obligatorily eusocial insects had to independently re-evolve multifemale breeding when that served the inclusive fitness interests of nursing workers. Multiqueen nesting (eusocial polygyny) is known to be common across the ants, but rare in the corbiculate (eusocial) bees, the vespine wasps and the higher termites, but we show that this difference is mostly due to cases of obligate polygyny being restricted to the ants. This pattern is remarkably similar to the distribution of inquiline social parasites that use stealth rather than aggression to invade host colonies, which also repeatedly evolved in ants only. We explore the lineage-specific selection forces that have allowed or constrained de novo evolution of stable eusocial polygyny in Hamiltonian inclusive fitness terms. We argue that perennial life histories, male survival as stored sperm rather than as lifetime mates, and sib competition are possibly sufficient to explain the general prevalence of secondary polygyny across the obligatorily eusocial insects. We infer that obligate polygyny compromises eusocial ‘soma’ and ‘germ-line’ segregation in ways known to decrease developmental stability in metazoans, and we briefly evaluate the selection forces that reduce queen life span in highly, but probably not facultatively, polygynous species. We conclude that secondary polygyny in its obligate (ant) form resembles cooperative breeding with multiple ‘tragedy of the commons’ aspects, but in a peculiar manner because breeding females are selected to exploit the services of unmated workers rather than each other’s. This breeding system has likely been maintained in ants because it allows modular extensions of colonies in directly adjacent habitat of similar quality without the re-emergence of sexual conflicts or unproductive local competition with kin.