The elevated toxicity of the biodegradation product (guanylurea) from metformin and the antagonistic pattern recognition of combined toxicity: Insight from the pharmaceutical risk assessment and the simulated wastewater treatment

Abstract

The emerging contaminants metformin (MET) and its degradation product guanylurea (GUA) are released into aquatic environments through wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). Thus, the environmental risks of wastewater with more treatments may be underestimated due to the lower effect concentration of GUA and the higher detected concentration of GUA in treated wastewater in comparison with MET. In this study, we aimed to investigate the combined toxicity mode of MET and GUA to Brachionus calyciflorus by simulating the degrees of wastewater treatments through adjustments to the ratio of MET and GUA in medium. The results showed that the 24 h-LC50 of MET, GUA, their mixtures of equal concentrations and the mixtures of equal toxic units to B. calyciflorus were 907.44, 544.53, 1185.82 and 940.52 mg/L, respectively, demonstrating GUA is significantly more toxic than MET. An antagonistic interaction between MET and GUA was found in mixture toxicity assessments. Compared with the control, MET treatments only significantly affected the intrinsic rate of population increase of rotifers (rm), while all life-table parameters were significantly affected by GUA. In addition, at medium and high concentrations (120 and 600 μmol/L), the net reproductive rate (R0) and rm of rotifers under GUA were significantly lower than those under MET. Notably, increased proportion of GUA relative to MET in binary-mixture treatments resulted in increased survival risk and reduced fecundity of rotifers. Moreover, the responses of population dynamics to exposures of MET and GUA were mainly attributed to the reproduction of rotifer, indicating that an improved wastewater treatment process is necessary to protect aquatic ecosystems. The study highlights the importance of considering the combined toxicity of emerging contaminants and degradation product in environmental risk assessment, especially the unintentional transformations of parent compound in treated wastewater.