The efficacy of second line chemotherapy (CHT) in platinum-sensitive advanced/metastatic small cell lung cancer (SCLC) patients: Results of an ongoing Italian multicenter survey

Abstract

18090 Background: Despite CHT and radiotherapy for SCLC, most patients (pts) die within 2 years. Response rates for second-line CHT are low, with a median survival of 5 months in platinum-refractory pts. Re-challenge with platinum salts or salvage regimens is a standard option for pts with platinum-sensitive disease with a median overall survival (OS) of 6.5–8 months (Chua et al., Cancer Treat Rev. 2004). The purpose of this study was to explore the benefits of different second line regimens in this platiunum sensitive population. Methods: Clinical records of 73 platinum sensitive SCLC pts (first line relapse free survival > 6 months) were reviewed from 13 medical oncology departments in Italy from January 1993 to December 2006. Pt. characteristics: 59 males, 14 females, median age 64 years (range 27–93), median ECOG performance status (PS): 1, limited/extended disease: 33/40 pts. Pts received salvage chemotherapy which consisted of monotherapy in 37% and platinum-containing doublets in 55%. Doublets without platinum salts were administered in the remaining 8%. Results: Of 67 evaluable pt, second line CHT produced partial responses (PR) in 58 (79%) and stable disease (SD) in 9 pts (12%) by RECIST criteria. Overall tumor growth control (PR+SD) was 91%. Despite these encouraging results, the median TTP was 3 months and OS for all evaluable pts was 6.5 months. Survival at 1 year was 11%. Multivariate analysis revealed that the most important prognostic factor for response was age ( p<0.04) and there was no statistically significant difference between platinum-based regimens and monotherapy. Multivariate analysis showed no impact on survival by prior response to first line treatment, female sex or smoking status. Conclusions: Within the limits of a retrospective study, despite the high rate of responses obtainable in this setting, TTP and OS do not appear significantly improved by salvage regimens. Second line CHT has marginal activity and should be considered only in younger pts with a good PS. On the basis of these results, re-treatment with platinum salts could be avoided in these pts. No significant financial relationships to disclose.