The effects of tillage systems and crop sequences on soil bulk density and penetration resistance on a clay soil in southern Saskatchewan

Abstract

Concern has been expressed that reduced tillage systems may lead to excess soil compaction, negatively impacting on crop growth. The objectives of this study were to determine the effects of tillage systems zero (ZT), minimum (MT) and conventional tillage (CT) and crop rotations on soil bulk density and penetration resistance after 4 yr on an Indian Head heavy clay soil, in southeastern Saskatchewan. Moisture content was similar among tillage systems, except for slight differences in the lower soil depths with crop rotation. Penetration resistance and bulk density of a heavy clay soil were increased in the surface 10 cm of the soil by ZT as compared to CT management. However, in the deeper soil zones, tillage system did not consistently influence either bulk density or penetration resistance. Inclusion of peas in the crop rotation had a moderating effect on bulk density and penetration resistance, while inclusion of flax in a continuous rotation increased bulk density and penetration resistance in the surface soil profile. At the 30- to 45-cm depth, ZT had a lower bulk density than CT or MT in the rotation which included fallow, possibly because the tillage operations associated with the cultivated fallow led to compaction in the deeper soil zone. Penetration resistance was great enough in the deeper soil zone in all tillage systems to restrict rooting, but difference due to tillage treatment or cropping rotation was not sufficient to markedly influence crop production. Key words: Penetration resistance, bulk density, crop rotation, tillage