The effects of litter quality and living plants on the home-field advantage of aquatic macrophyte decomposition in a eutrophic urban lake, China

Abstract

The ‘home-field advantage’ (HFA) hypothesis states that litter decomposes faster in its ‘home’ habitat, i.e., in the same habitat as the plant species from which it was derived than it does ‘away’ from its home, i.e., in the habitat of a different plant species. However, studies pertaining to HFA in aquatic ecosystems are relatively few. One area not well-studied is whether the presence of living plants has an effect on the HFA of aquatic macrophyte decomposition in a eutrophic lake. Here, we conducted reciprocal litter transplanting experiments, coupled with removal of living plants, between a dominant submerged macrophyte (Myriophyllum spicatum) and a floating-leaved macrophyte (Trapa natans) in a eutrophic urban lake in China, for 50 days. Test plots were created at sites by removing the dominant macrophytes from their ‘home’ habitats to test the effect of living plants on decomposition rates and HFA effect. The water chemistry of the two sites was not significantly different. The initial litter qualities were significantly higher in M. spicatum than in T. natans. The decomposition rates of T. natans were significantly greater in both the control and test plots in its ‘home’ habitat, indicating a positive HFA effect, while the decomposition rates of M. spicatum were significantly greater in the ‘away’ habitat compared to its ‘home’ habitat in all treatments, indicating a home-field disadvantage effect. The removal of living plants had a noticeable effect on the abundance of associated-macroinvertebrates, but had an inconsistent effect on decomposition rates providing conflicting evidence for HFA. In total, 10 macroinvertebrate taxa from four functional feeding groups (FFGs) were collected during the experiment. Compared to macroinvertebrate communities, microbial activities showed less correlation with decomposition rates. Our results provide evidence to suggest that decomposition-based HFA is dependent upon litter quality, habitat, and their interactions in a eutrophic urban lake.