The effects of anthropogenic alteration of nesting habitat on rates of extra‐pair fertilization and intraspecific brood parasitism in Canada Geese Branta canadensis

Abstract

Parentage studies have shown that alternative reproductive strategies are widespread in many avian taxa that were once thought to be monogamous. Recent anthropogenically mediated habitat change may have disrupted ecological factors, such as breeding density, which have given rise to inter‐ and intraspecific variation in the frequency of extra‐pair fertilization (EPF) and intraspecific brood parasitism (IBP). We used genetic analyses to quantify the incidence of alternative reproductive strategies exhibited within clutches of Canada Geese Branta canadensis maxima nesting in high‐ and low‐density situations in and around urban areas in southern Michigan, USA. We tested the hypothesis that high nesting density would increase the frequency of EPF and IBP. There were no significant differences in rates of EPF and IBP clutches (14 and 26% of clutches, respectively) from nests in high‐density (21.7% EPF, 21.7% IBP) vs. low‐density (5.3% EPF, 31.6% IBP) areas, although high‐density sites had a fourfold higher rate of EPF. Rates of EPF and IBP in high‐density urban areas in Michigan were comparable to rates observed in other species nesting under different ecological conditions. Levels of relatedness between host and parasitic females were higher than expected by chance, suggesting that related females are more tolerant of one another and that host females could gain inclusive fitness benefits from rearing parasitic offspring. Our study highlights the importance of understanding the different costs and benefits associated with alternative behavioural repertoires that may vary as habitats and associated selection pressures are increasingly modified by human activities.