The Effectiveness of Tape Playback in Estimating Black Rail Density

Abstract

Tape playhack is often the only efficient technique to survey for secretive birds We measured the vocal responses and movements of radiotagged black rails Laterallus jamaicensis; 26 M, 17 F to pl k of vocalizations at 2 sites in Florida during the breeding seasons of 1992-95. We used coefficients fron logistic regression equations to model probability of a respouse conditional to the birds' sex, nesting status, distance to playback source, and time of urvey. With a probability of 0.811, nonnesting male black rails were most likely to respond to playback, while nesting females were the least likely to respond (probability = 0.189). We used linear regression to determine daily, monthly, and annual variation in response from weekly playback surveys along a fixed route during the breeding seasons of 1993-95. Significant sources of variation in the regression model were month (F 3.48 = 3.89, P = 0.014), year (F 2.48 = 9.37, P < 0.001), temperature (F 1.48 = 5.44, P = 0.024), and month × year (F 5.18 = 2.69, P = 0.031). The model was highly significant (P < 0.001) and explained 54% of the variation of mean response per survey period (r 2 = 0.54). We combined response probability data from radiotagged black rails with playback survey route data to provide a density estimate of 0.25 birds/ha for the St. Johns National Wildlife Refuge The relation between the number of black rails heard during playback surveys to the actual number present was influenced by a number of variables We recommend caution when making density estimates from tape playback surveys.