The effect of upper panel stiffness on biomechanical performance in athletic footwear

Abstract

Athletic footwear can improve performance through targeted design features to improve biomechanical mechanisms of performance. The alteration of athletic shoe uppers can impact athletic performance and biomechanics in both males and females; moreover, the impact may differ between males and females due to anatomical differences between sexes. Therefore, assessment of sex-specific impacts of footwear modification on athletic performance is essential when determining how to modify footwear. The purpose of this research was to determine the impact of upper panel stiffness on biomechanical performance during agility tasks and determine if the optimal upper stiffness depends on the sex of the athlete. It was hypothesized that stiffening the upper panel, quantified through uniaxial tension testing, would result in decreased contact time and increased force production during jumping and change of direction tasks. Forty participants (20 males, 20 females) were recruited and completed eight lateral skater jumps, eight counter movement jumps, three triangle drop step drills and six anterior-posterior drills in three footwear conditions that varied in upper panel stiffness. 3D motion capture and embedded force plates were used to measure biomechanical outcomes that were compared between stiffness conditions using a linear mixed effect model. Upper panel stiffness significantly affected contact time during the lateral skater jump with the stiffest shoe resulting in the shortest contact time compared to the two other conditions (p = .02–.046, η2 = 0.18). No sex-related interactions were found for any outcome variable. Taken together, upper panel stiffness is important to consider when developing both male and female footwear.